• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Spain
  • Portugal
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Culture
    • IberoArts
      • Books
      • Music
      • Films
  • Iberoblog
    • Videos
  • About Iberosphere
    • Contributors
    • Contact
    • Fine print
      • Privacy Policy
      • Disclaimer
      • Copyright

Iberosphere

News, comment and analysis on Spain, Portugal and beyond

Smoking ban: where’s the sense?

March 1, 2011 by Nick Lyne 2 Comments

But on January 2, the government finally pushed through the EU’s most stringent anti-smoking legislation, ignoring a common sense solution.

Aside from the economic impact on bars, and treating us like children, there will be other negative effects. People living in the centre of cities, and particularly those living above bars, will find that when the warm weather comes there will be a lot more noise in the street below them as people gather for a smoke outside bars, and allow their deadly cancerous smoke to drift up to their balconies.

Imagine yourself, a non-smoker, sitting next to a terrace table on a hot afternoon or evening, with not so much as a breeze in the air, and four people at the next table light up. Will bars have to place fans outside to blow smoke away?

Of far greater impact will be the loss of one of the more civilized things about this country that the ban will bring about. Until now, when you ordered your drink in a bar, you weren’t charged until you left. A small thing, you might think, but such a tradition reflects a society where the bar is a place where all are welcome, and trusted to play by the rules. Sadly, faced with growing numbers of customers who use the excuse of nipping out for a cigarette to then waltz off without paying once outside, bar owners are increasingly charging customers as they order.

Finally, the obvious question: if tobacco is really so dangerous as to justify a ban on its use in public places, surely the thing to do would be to add cigarettes and other tobacco products to the long list of substances our governments feel they must protect us from.

A clue: shortly after introducing the ban, this government also raised taxes on tobacco products, estimating that the hike would net around 780 million euros this year.

I’m no smoker, but if I were, I’d be inclined to give up, if only to deprive the government of a dishonest tax.

Filed Under: Iberoblog Tagged With: cigarette tax, cigarettes, smoking, Spain smoking, Spain smoking ban, spain smoking law, spain tobacco, tobacco, tobacco tax

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Ian Murphy says

    March 1, 2011 at 8:08 pm

    The ‘common sense solution’ was a non-solution. 100% of bars opted to be smoking bars. There wasn’t a single non-smoking bar, out of a couple of hundred, in the areas near where I live and work

    >will find that when the warm weather comes there
    >will be a lot more noise in the street below them as people
    >gather for a smoke outside bars

    Hardly, in the summer most bars are completely empty – everyone is standing around in the street with a cold caña in their hand.

    >Sadly, faced with growing numbers of customers who use the excuse
    >of nipping out for a cigarette to then waltz off without paying once
    >outside, bar owners are increasingly charging customers as they order.

    Thats ridiculous claim. It has always been normal for people to take their drinks outside, smokers or not. Its common to see streets outside bars full of people talking and laughing in the summer, they then go back in to pay. Nothing has changed … except that the whiners are now outside rather than inside.
    Thieves have always walked away without paying and will do so if they are smokers or not.

    >and four people at the next table light up.
    >Will bars have to place fans outside to blow smoke away

    The law is very clear on that, no. Its not an enclosed space.

    >Finally, the obvious question: if tobacco is really so dangerous as to
    >justify a ban on its use in public places

    Dangerous or not, its finally pleasant to be able sit at the bar and eat something without having the fat guy next to you blow putrid cigar smoke across your face the whole time.

    Hardly anyone I know smokes and those that do don’t smoke much. Not one is complaining about the change.

    Log in to Reply
    • Malcolm says

      March 2, 2011 at 9:59 pm

      Ian-totally agree with you,as will almost everyone else.You should see the previous “attempt” by this so-called journalist,even more dreadful than this article. This-Wednesday, November 10th, 2010 |
      Spain’s smoking ban: stubbing out freedom or

      https://iberosphere.com/2010/11/spain-news-smoking-ban-stubbing-out-freedom/1634#comment-21078

      It makes that pillock in Andalusia almost intelligent

      Log in to Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

The End

Iberosphere calls it a day after three-and-a-half years

Recent Comments

  • Tim on What I learned in a Spanish brothel
  • tom scott on Sex and the Spanish single lady
  • tom scott on What I learned in a Spanish brothel
  • Matt on Sex and the Spanish single lady
  • betty on Madrid, capital of the special advertising section

Recent Posts

  • The End
  • Maybe Rajoy is right: deny everything and it’ll go away
  • A slow death in the afternoon
  • Tales for Tapas: Leaving Spain
  • Spain ahead of the US in bankers’ prosecution

Copyright © 2025 · Iberosphere · Log in